The Lusaka High Court has directed Brian Mundubile and Makebi Zulu to first seek bail from the Subordinate Court handling their seditious practices case, declining to proceed with their application before it.
The direction followed the Court’s consideration of preliminary issues raised by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) and his legal team.
In its ruling, the Court said the issues raised by the State concerned judicial comity, the avoidance of parallel proceedings and the orderly exercise of jurisdiction by courts of coordinate authority.
“The questions raised are not without substance. They touch upon important considerations of judicial comity and orderly procedure. They also touch as much upon the avoidance of parallel proceedings as on the proper exercise of the jurisdiction of Judges of coordinate jurisdiction,” the Court observed.
The Court noted that the applicants had appeared before the Lusaka Subordinate Court after filing their bail application and that the trial court had already been constituted.
It therefore held that the appropriate course was for the applicants to first seek bail before the court handling their trial.
Should the Subordinate Court refuse bail, Mundubile and Zulu would be at liberty to return to the High Court to renew or escalate their application.
The Court also clarified that it retained jurisdiction to hear bail applications, addressing one of the preliminary issues raised by the DPP.
It further held that the proceedings before the Lusaka High Court and those before the Solwezi High Court involved different questions and sought different relief, meaning there were no concerns of multiplicity of proceedings.
Read More: State seeks to block video evidence in Mundubile bail case, as they return to court
The Court also clarified that Section 123(3) of the Criminal Procedure Code did not require an unsuccessful bail application before a Subordinate Court as a precondition for the High Court to exercise its jurisdiction.
Although the Court did not uphold the State’s preliminary objections as legal barriers to its jurisdiction, its final direction means the applicants must first pursue bail before the trial court.
The ruling was procedural and determined the appropriate forum and sequence for considering the bail application.
It did not determine whether bail should ultimately be granted or address the merits of the seditious practices charges, which remain before the Subordinate Court.
Mundubile and Zulu remain presumed innocent until proven guilty.
WARNING! All rights reserved. This material, and other digital content on this website, may not be reproduced, published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in whole or in part without prior express permission from ZAMBIA MONITOR.













Comments